Shooter: Brewster's big regret as Gophers coach: the spread offense

BleedGopher

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 11, 2008
Messages
60,883
Reaction score
16,455
Points
113
http://www.twincities.com/sports/ci_18991042?nclick_check=1

Tim Brewster, fired last year midway through his fourth season as University of Minnesota football coach, said he has one major regret about his tenure with the Gophers.

"I made a mistake trying to bring the spread offense into Minnesota," Brewster, talking extensively for the first time publicly since his dismissal last October, said Tuesday.

"It wasn't the right thing to do. It helped us in recruiting; it didn't help us on the field. That's a sincere regret that I have. I fixed it and changed. But coming out of the gate, if I would have done the things we did in our fourth year, we would have been much further ahead and had a much greater chance for success."

Brewster's Gophers teams finished 15-30 overall, 6-21 in the Big Ten.

"We came in with a spread offense because we did not have the athletes we needed to have to compete in the Big Ten, so I really felt running a spread offense would allow us to recruit better," Brewster said. "Once we got our recruits in, I wanted to evolve to more of a ground-based attack, what I call 'an all-weather attack.'

"What it did, though, is get me behind the eight-ball - the time we spent on the spread was not time well spent. That's something that I regret to this day."

Brewster said he later realized his teams needed to be a "ground-based offense, play-action pass, and then truly build your team around the defense. The biggest problem that Minnesota's had forever is that they haven't been able to stop anybody.

"The biggest regret, in my mind, is that we probably could have transitioned quicker."

These days, Brewster is a NFL and college sideline reporter for Fox Sports. He'll work Saturday night's Texas at Iowa State game, then drive to Kansas City, Mo., to work the sideline in the Chiefs-Vikings game Sunday afternoon.

"I'm enjoying it; it keeps me close to the game I love," Brewster said. "And I'm around good guys - (broadcasting partners) Charles Davis and Gus Johnson are two of the best. And Fox is a first-class operation. Next year truly becomes a battle between Fox and ESPN for the king of college football kind of deal."

Brewster's son Nolan, who was a starting junior strong safety for Texas this season, this week decided to quit playing football.

"A hard deal; football's been his life," Tim said. "He had a big-time concussion last week in the UCLA game, and he had been having some contact-related migraines. (Medical officials) have a hard time deciphering between the symptoms of a migraine and concussion. So, is it eight migraines, or is it five migraines and three concussions?"

Texas flew Nolan to see a specialist at the University of Michigan. After a consultation, Nolan, who will graduate in May with a double major in business, decided to stop playing.

"He made the right decision," his father said. "He said, 'My body was trying to tell me something, that maybe I don't need to be doing this right now.' This is the deal: Every time he lined up, he was playing Russian roulette. 'On this hit, was I going to get one (concussion), get a migraine? Maybe I didn't get it on this one, but ...' "

Brewster, who received a $600,000 contract buyout after annual compensation worth $1 million annually, still owns a house in suburban Minneapolis that he's renting out, has a condo in Naples, Fla., and has moved to Chapel Hill, N.C., where he's renting a home formerly owned by Texas coach Mack Brown.

"It's been a hard year, but it's all worked out really well," he said.

Brewster keeps track of and loves the Gophers.

"(Coach) Jerry Kill and I have had a previous friendship, and I love those kids," he said. "Those are my kids. They had such a great opening game (a 19-17 loss at Southern California). Those kids played really well and hard. The past couple of weeks have been unfortunate - they're going through a really hard situation (Kill's seizure disorder) with their head coach. That's a hard, tough deal. You'd like to see (Kill) take whatever time is necessary to fix it."

Brewster hasn't talked publicly about his dismissal by Minnesota.

"When you're as emotionally involved in a deal as I was in that one, and what happens happens, you sometimes get caught saying the wrong thing, being emotional about your responses," he said. "So I deliberately tried to back away from it. It is what it is, and you move on. That's kind of where I'm at now with it.

"I certainly still have very strong feelings about those kids I recruited to the University of Minnesota, and want them to have success. And I met some of the best people I've ever met in my life in Minnesota, some great, great people who are lifelong friends.

"I loved everything about it."

Will Brewster coach again?

"We'll see; I'm a coach by nature, that's who I am, and I'm a darn good one," he said. "I'm not a guy whose ego says I have to be a head coach. To me, it's all about the people, so much more than it is about the job itself. If the opportunity presents itself to work for somebody who would inspire me, fire me up, shoot, I'd do it in a heartbeat."

Brewster's current focus is to see how good he can be as an analyst. His role with Fox is to be a third analyst from the sideline.

"For 25 years, I watched football from the sideline," he said. "This is to really get a coach's perspective from the field. At different points during the game, I give my views on what's happening on the field, what I'm seeing. I'm right where I've always been."

And what about the Vikings and the Chiefs on Sunday? Brewster hasn't lost any hyperbole.

"It's an absolutely huge game, a playoff game (in terms) of the mentality both teams have to take into it," Brewster said. "There's one team in National Football League history that opened the season 0-4 and made the playoffs - that's the 1992 San Diego Chargers."

Brewster spent three seasons as a Chargers assistant.

"I've got great experience in Arrowhead Stadium - I competed against the Chiefs twice a year, and it's one of the toughest places in the National Football League to play, extremely tough," he said. "To me, the Vikings will have to be on their 'A' game.

"The Vikings need to wear Adrian Peterson out. The ball's not heavy - give it to him a bunch. I would give it to him until he couldn't hold it anymore."

Go Gophers!!
 

Interesting take from Brew.
 

I don't really understand why he does not live in either his place in Florida or MN. He owns two places yet rents at a third. Doesn't make a lot of sense to me.

As for the substance, bringing in the spread was a mistake, but at the time it did not seem to be; at least not to me (granted I am not a HC). It certainly has hurt this team now as we do not have the right players to run a pro-style offense. Oh well, that is what the Kill hire was for - to fix Brewster's mistakes.

Best of luck Brew.
 

I respect Tim Brewster. He tried and failed...there you go.
 

I think that is a good article, and makes me feel a lot more sympathetic to brewster. He takes a lot of crap on this board and from gopher fans, but the dude really did pour his heart and soul into the job. He was definitely over matched for the position, but I can't blame a guy for being offered a job.
 





The spread was a radical departure from the previous offense. He would have been better off keeping the offense intact (or at least making a less radical change) and working on the defense.
 



Wish Brewster nothing but the best.

With respect to why he doesn't live in either house he owns, just look at the time when he probably bought his Minnesota house. I'm guessing he owes a lot more on it than what it is worth and if memory serves me, it was pretty lavish. Now that he's making less salary he probably wouldn't be able to afford it if he lived there, but by renting it out he can probably get by until the market improves to where he could sell it and not lose a ton of money.
 

Wish Brewster nothing but the best.

With respect to why he doesn't live in either house he owns, just look at the time when he probably bought his Minnesota house. I'm guessing he owes a lot more on it than what it is worth and if memory serves me, it was pretty lavish. Now that he's making less salary he probably wouldn't be able to afford it if he lived there, but by renting it out he can probably get by until the market improves to where he could sell it and not lose a ton of money.

Very true...and nobody actually lives in Naples year round unless you are 70 and dying...so that place I am sure is just a vacation spot for his family. Plus if he is travelling around the US...the Naples airport isn't one you want to make your home base.
 

Maturi probably forgot to tell Brewster the U was building a new outdoor stadium.

BTW did anyone notice the lack of tremendous(s)

Northwestern won 3 B10 titles after putting in the spread. IMO, we never had the QB to run it.
 

I realize I'm in the minority on this, but I think if he had stayed with Dunbar and the spread offense, then he's probably still the head coach here. Weber would have led the team to a couple of decent bowl games and Gray would be doing okay now, too.
 



I'll agree with that, it might have been a mistake in making such a radical switch in the offense, but having made that, making yet another radical switch compounded the problem. A better offense would have hidden some of the weaknesses in last year's defense.
 

I tip my hat to Brewster for his tremendous effort and I wish him well.

The fact is he had more issues than deciding what offense to run.
 

His hyperbole wore on my Scandinavian sensibilities a bit, but I always thought Brewster was a stand-up guy and this article bears that out. I always thought he was too competitive for his own good and that his impatience (and lack of head coaching experience) created the constant coordinator shuffle.

Anyway, I wish him well.
 

Northwestern won 3 B10 titles after putting in the spread. IMO, we never had the QB to run it.

Joe Tiller and Purdue also got one in 2000 running it. They got to two January Bowls and 10 Bowls in a 12 year stretch running it.

Brewster's Offense wasn't the problem, the Defense was. They put up a lot of points and Weber threw and ran for a lot of yards with it those first two years.The first year Dunbar's stubborn refusal to run anything BUT the Spread killed it. They'd be 3rd and 1 and he'd insist on hiking the ball back 5 yards plus away from the line of scrimmage.

They did all right with it in 2008 until injuries, starting with Decker, exposed their lack of depth culminating with the debacle against Iowa. Hell, the Gophers had walking wounded and 3rd and 4th stringers on the field in that damned game. That resulted in the crap we had to watch the last couple of years.

They would have won a few more games this past couple of years if Brewster had let Weber (or Gray) take off when the field was open or hadn't insisted in trying to establish a running game when, even then, they did their best work through the air.

Studwell's probably right, he usually is, about the spread long term not working up here. That said, the majority of Gopher fans though certainly would take Northwestern and Purdue's record with it.

http://www.twincities.com/sports
 

I realize I'm in the minority on this, but I think if he had stayed with Dunbar and the spread offense, then he's probably still the head coach here. Weber would have led the team to a couple of decent bowl games and Gray would be doing okay now, too.
I completely agree. I think the problem was firing Dunbar and moving away from the spread. Weber and Gray are both perfect for the spread offense. Didn't Weber rush for over 800 yards as a freshman? I think he threw 24 TD's his freshman year. His biggest mistake here was moving to that pro style offense when we didn't have the right players to run it.
 

Re: Weber
Fine spread QB athlete, but never could read a defense and was so inconsistent with his passing accuracy. That is why the spread failed under Brewster.
 

Bingo.

Weber wasn't accurate enough. He has a good arm (watch some of his seam throws over the past few years), but he wasn't accurate enough for the spread. Purdue & Northwestern had some NICE QB's to make their system go. Brees, Kustok, Orton, Painter, Basanez, Bacher, Kafka.....
 

Bingo.

Weber wasn't accurate enough. He has a good arm (watch some of his seam throws over the past few years), but he wasn't accurate enough for the spread. Purdue & Northwestern had some NICE QB's to make their system go. Brees, Kustok, Orton, Painter, Basanez, Bacher, Kafka.....

Admittedly his numbers were awful the last two years, but then he was throwing only when he had to. Many times he had to wait and wait for someone to get open rather then taking-off running. Did he make some lousy throws then? Sure he did but the point is he shouldn't have made many of those throws in the first place. Now throw in no threat of a run game, a heck of a lot of drops and it's a wonder that he didn't look even worse.

Here are his Passing numbers from 2007 and 2008.

258 of 449 (57.5%) for 2,895 yards and 255 of 410 (62.2%) for 2,761 yards. Those are all in the Top Ten all time for the Gophers. Let him run the same Offense in 09 and 10, keep getting players for the system and let Weber/Gray take off when no one was open and there has to be 2-4 wins more each year.

Now of course it's all moot. I wish it was "mute" but there it is.
 

I didn't like the spread, but I'll politely disagree with those who believe Weber wasn't built for the offense. This is only my opinion, but I thought Weber did better under the spread because the check-downs are a lot easier than in a pro-set. There's always going to be a "hot" receiver in the spread. It was when Weber went to the pro-set that he had problems with reads in my view.

The problem for the Gophers running the spread is that they didn't have the offensive line play to prevent the offense from being totally overwhelmed by defenses. The key to the spread is to take away the QBs running option with blitzes and stunts, which opponents were very successful with doing against the Gophers.
 

I'll agree with that, it might have been a mistake in making such a radical switch in the offense, but having made that, making yet another radical switch compounded the problem. A better offense would have hidden some of the weaknesses in last year's defense.

Even if he fired Dunbar, I thought he had a much better chance of remaining employed if he kept the Spread. Once he made that decision day one to go with the spread, he needed to stick with. When he switched he wrote his own dismissal.

Of course, none of that helps the other side of the ball, which was a bigger problem...

I hope he learns from this and can be a good coach somewhere in the future.
 

Agreed, there were plenty of other spread coordinators. There's a reason that coaches have systems that they stick with. Successful coaches tend to stick with what they do for the long term. I don't know what Brewster intends to do, whether he's going to continue covering games for TV, or if he wants to break back into coaching. It's unlikely that he could get another BCS job, so he'd have to find a job with a non-BCS or FCS team. There's always D-II, but he'd probably make a lot more money doing TV than in being a D-II coach.
 

Agreed 100% with Brewster. Gopher priorities should be: 1) defense, 2) run the ball, 3) play action pass, 4) drop back pass only when have to, 5) shot gun pass for hail mary or 3rd and forever/obvious blitz
 

I like Brewster but doesn't this show his lack of depth?

Can't you focus on defense and run the spread. It is not like they are mutually exclusive. You could do both.
 

you can tell he is sincere and still cares for the kids in this interview

He is right about implementing the spread being the wrong type of offense from day one, that and hiring Withers the first year were two big mistakes that compounded each other. The spread with an inaccurate passer and a bad defense equal disaster even if you are trying to mitigate your deficiencies. That and hiring Miller as the O line coach were bad ideas, that got Brewster off on the wrong foot. If he would have had year 4 coaches from the beginning and did not try such a radical change in offensive philosophies he might actually still be here.
 

I think once he went spread, he had to stick with it, or what happened was bound to happen. You recruited to the spread for two years, and then, flip the switch to a completely different style. Very risky move and he paid dearly for it. I don't think we see the 3-9 year if we're still running spread in Year 4. But of course, that likely means he's still employed here right now, who knows. I just think that was a bad mistake to flip it up like that after only 2 years.
 

The Kessel, 19 November 1942 – 31 January 1943

BleedGopher,
1. How well I remember the staff of GopherHole running “The Loon” out of town and banning him for having the audacity to declare that “the spread” at Minnesota is a really bad idea. Most everybody on this board threw verbal rotten eggs, and spoiled vegetables at him.
2. “The Loon” on GopherHole reminds me of Cassandra’s plight. She predicted the future accurately and repeatedly, yet none of her fellow countrymen would listen to her.
3. GopherHole staff: Congratulate yourselves for banning “The Loon.” For your heroic actions, why don’t you nominate yourselves for a Silver Star?
4. I pray Jerry Kill and his staff break us out of The Kessel entrapment which Joel Maturi led us into.
 

First off, his personnel mistakes were his first mistake even before the spread. I know this is stormy, but he really should have held on to Shaw and the RB coach, though I am not sure either could have coached well under the spread. They did not have the personnel to run the spread, but his continually changing OC and systems each year did not help either.

As for the Def., I think Withers is doing all right now, and it would have been much better if he could have smoothed things over with Roof, though that was unlikely once pride got ruffled.

Otherwise, he came and tried, but did not succeed. Best wishes to him.

As for the
 




Top Bottom