I went through analysis to compare both programs talent from previous coaches recruits at the two year mark.
This is using only players from recruiting classes that showed on the 247 website so JUCO's that didn't sign as part of a class on 247 and walkons not listed on those classes are not included.
Players recruited but with no 247 ranking were given a ranking of 0.7500.
This takes both coaches at the start of their second year.
Kill 2nd Year (2012)
Recruiter Recruit Class Yr Class During Season Qty Avg Rating
Brewster 2008 RS Sr. 8 0.8691
Brewster 2009 RS Jr. - Sr. 13 0.8453
Brewster 2010 RS So. - Jr. 14 0.8325
Total players from previous coach: 35
Avg Ranking 0.8460
RS Junior, Seniors, or RS Seniors: 21
Fleck 2nd Year (2018)
Recruiter Recruit Class Yr Class During Season Qty Avg Rating
Kill 2014 RS Sr. 3 0.8053
Kill 2015 RS Jr. - Sr. 10 0.8268
Claeys 2016 RS So. - Jr. 14 0.8494
Total players from previous coach: 27
Avg Ranking 0.8303
RS Junior, Seniors, or RS Seniors: 10
At the first year in, both coaches were left with the following number of recruited players:
Kill in 2011: 55
Fleck in 2017: 47
These are the inherited players for each coach 2 years in.
Year Coach Name Size Rating
2008 Brewster MarQueis GrayBen Davis (Indianapolis, IN) 6-4 / 205 0.9143
2008 Brewster Keanon CooperSkyline (Dallas, TX) 6-0 / 190 0.8969
2008 Brewster Brandon GreenRobeson (Chicago, IL) 6-0 / 170 0.8938
2008 Brewster Spencer ReevesSkyline (Dallas, TX) 6-1 / 193 0.8733
2008 Brewster Troy StoudermireSkyline (Dallas, TX) 5-10 / 163 0.8542
2008 Brewster Deleon EskridgeJunipero Serra (San Mateo, CA) 5-11 / 181 0.851
2008 Brewster D.L. WilhiteBryan Station (Lexington, KY) 6-4 / 235 0.8417
2008 Brewster Ryan GrantEden Prairie (Eden Prairie, MN) 6-1 / 215 0.8274
2009 Brewster Ben PerrySouthlake Carroll (Southlake, TX) 6-5 / 253 0.7778
2009 Brewster Cameron WilsonRockwall-Heath (Rockwall, TX) 6-3 / 215 0.8111
2009 Brewster Dan OrseskeBrother Rice (Oak Lawn, IL) 6-3 / 195 0.8226
2009 Brewster Eric JacquesBlanche Ely (Pompano Beach, FL) 6-2 / 280 0.8333
2009 Brewster Brooks MichelCarmel (Carmel, IN) 6-7 / 280 0.8354
2009 Brewster Ed OlsonMahtomedi Senior (Saint Paul, MN) 6-7 / 285 0.8497
2009 Brewster Victor KeiseNorth Broward Prep (Pompano Beach, FL) 6-1 / 160 0.8528
2009 Brewster Kenneth WatkinsBrother Rice (Bloomfield Hills, MI) 6-0 / 185 0.8622
2009 Brewster Matt GarinEastview Senior (Saint Paul, MN) 6-4 / 220 0.8843
2009 Brewster Ra'shede HagemanWashburn (Minneapolis, MN) 6-6 / 250 0.8863
2009 Brewster Michael CarterBlanche Ely (Pompano Beach, FL) 5-11 / 160 0.9127
2009 Brewster Moses AlipateJefferson Senior (Alexandria, MN) 6-5 / 230 0.9177
2009 Brewster Zach MottlaCretin Derham Hall (Saint Paul, MN) - / - 0.75
2010 Brewster Logan HuttonLa Marque (La Marque, TX) 6-1 / 190 0.7667
2010 Brewster Sean FergusonHun School (Princeton, NJ) 6-6 / 303 0.8
2010 Brewster Dwayne MitchellEdna Karr (New Orleans, LA) 6-2 / 220 0.8368
2010 Brewster Zac EppingTremper (Kenosha, WI) 6-2 / 274 0.8385
2010 Brewster Harold LeganiaEdna Karr (New Orleans, LA) 6-3 / 250 0.8448
2010 Brewster Marek LenkiewiczVictor J Andrew (Bolingbrook, IL) 6-5 / 250 0.8484
2010 Brewster Devon WrightJ. P. Taravella (Pompano Beach, FL) 6-0 / 190 0.8573
2010 Brewster Brock VereenValencia (Valencia, CA) 6-0 / 175 0.859
2010 Brewster Donnell KirkwoodAtlantic (Delray Beach, FL) 5-10 / 197 0.8622
2010 Brewster James ManuelWarren Central (Indianapolis, IN) 6-2 / 200 0.8653
2010 Brewster Lamonte EdwardsWoodbury Senior (Saint Paul, MN) 6-2 / 215 0.8813
2010 Brewster Jimmy GjereIrondale Senior (Saint Paul, MN) 6-7 / 300 0.9072
2010 Brewster James GillumPearl River (Pearl River, LA) 5-11 / 190 0.75
2010 Brewster Dexter ForemanManvel (Manvel, TX) 6-1 / 220 0.75
Year Name Size Rating
2014 Jerry Gibson 6-3 / 220 0.815
2014 Jared Weyler 6-4 / 280 0.8015
2014 Gary Moore 6-4 / 285 0.7993
2015 Winston DeLattiboudere 6-3 / 216 0.8347
2015 Shannon Brooks 6-0 / 205 0.8431
2015 Quinn Oseland 6-6 / 301 0.8553
2015 Julian Huff 6-0 / 225 0.8033
2015 Jonathan Femi-Cole 6-0 / 218 0.827
2015 Jacob Huff 5-10 / 205 0.8155
2015 Colton Beebe 6-3 / 252 0.7996
2015 Bryce Witham 6-4 / 240 0.8219
2015 Bronson Dovich 6-5 / 295 0.8391
2015 Antonio Shenault 5-11 / 185 0.8284
2016 Tyler Johnson 6-3 / 187 0.8643
2016 Thomas Barber 6-1 / 225 0.8425
2016 Tai'yon Devers 6-4 / 220 0.8301
2016 Seth Green 6-4 / 216 0.8813
2016 Sam Schlueter 6-6 / 290 0.8603
2016 Phillip Howard 5-11 / 185 0.8509
2016 Ko Kieft 6-4 / 230 0.8037
2016 Kiondre Thomas 6-0 / 181 0.8466
2016 Kamal Martin 6-4 / 230 0.8518
2016 Donnell Greene 6-7 / 345 0.7933
2016 Conner Olson 6-5 / 295 0.8441
2016 Coney Durr 5-10.5 / 193 0.8375
2016 Carter Coughlin 6-4 / 223 0.9566
2016 Antoine Winfield 5-10 / 196 0.8285
This is using only players from recruiting classes that showed on the 247 website so JUCO's that didn't sign as part of a class on 247 and walkons not listed on those classes are not included.
Players recruited but with no 247 ranking were given a ranking of 0.7500.
This takes both coaches at the start of their second year.
Kill 2nd Year (2012)
Recruiter Recruit Class Yr Class During Season Qty Avg Rating
Brewster 2008 RS Sr. 8 0.8691
Brewster 2009 RS Jr. - Sr. 13 0.8453
Brewster 2010 RS So. - Jr. 14 0.8325
Total players from previous coach: 35
Avg Ranking 0.8460
RS Junior, Seniors, or RS Seniors: 21
Fleck 2nd Year (2018)
Recruiter Recruit Class Yr Class During Season Qty Avg Rating
Kill 2014 RS Sr. 3 0.8053
Kill 2015 RS Jr. - Sr. 10 0.8268
Claeys 2016 RS So. - Jr. 14 0.8494
Total players from previous coach: 27
Avg Ranking 0.8303
RS Junior, Seniors, or RS Seniors: 10
At the first year in, both coaches were left with the following number of recruited players:
Kill in 2011: 55
Fleck in 2017: 47
These are the inherited players for each coach 2 years in.
Year Coach Name Size Rating
2008 Brewster MarQueis GrayBen Davis (Indianapolis, IN) 6-4 / 205 0.9143
2008 Brewster Keanon CooperSkyline (Dallas, TX) 6-0 / 190 0.8969
2008 Brewster Brandon GreenRobeson (Chicago, IL) 6-0 / 170 0.8938
2008 Brewster Spencer ReevesSkyline (Dallas, TX) 6-1 / 193 0.8733
2008 Brewster Troy StoudermireSkyline (Dallas, TX) 5-10 / 163 0.8542
2008 Brewster Deleon EskridgeJunipero Serra (San Mateo, CA) 5-11 / 181 0.851
2008 Brewster D.L. WilhiteBryan Station (Lexington, KY) 6-4 / 235 0.8417
2008 Brewster Ryan GrantEden Prairie (Eden Prairie, MN) 6-1 / 215 0.8274
2009 Brewster Ben PerrySouthlake Carroll (Southlake, TX) 6-5 / 253 0.7778
2009 Brewster Cameron WilsonRockwall-Heath (Rockwall, TX) 6-3 / 215 0.8111
2009 Brewster Dan OrseskeBrother Rice (Oak Lawn, IL) 6-3 / 195 0.8226
2009 Brewster Eric JacquesBlanche Ely (Pompano Beach, FL) 6-2 / 280 0.8333
2009 Brewster Brooks MichelCarmel (Carmel, IN) 6-7 / 280 0.8354
2009 Brewster Ed OlsonMahtomedi Senior (Saint Paul, MN) 6-7 / 285 0.8497
2009 Brewster Victor KeiseNorth Broward Prep (Pompano Beach, FL) 6-1 / 160 0.8528
2009 Brewster Kenneth WatkinsBrother Rice (Bloomfield Hills, MI) 6-0 / 185 0.8622
2009 Brewster Matt GarinEastview Senior (Saint Paul, MN) 6-4 / 220 0.8843
2009 Brewster Ra'shede HagemanWashburn (Minneapolis, MN) 6-6 / 250 0.8863
2009 Brewster Michael CarterBlanche Ely (Pompano Beach, FL) 5-11 / 160 0.9127
2009 Brewster Moses AlipateJefferson Senior (Alexandria, MN) 6-5 / 230 0.9177
2009 Brewster Zach MottlaCretin Derham Hall (Saint Paul, MN) - / - 0.75
2010 Brewster Logan HuttonLa Marque (La Marque, TX) 6-1 / 190 0.7667
2010 Brewster Sean FergusonHun School (Princeton, NJ) 6-6 / 303 0.8
2010 Brewster Dwayne MitchellEdna Karr (New Orleans, LA) 6-2 / 220 0.8368
2010 Brewster Zac EppingTremper (Kenosha, WI) 6-2 / 274 0.8385
2010 Brewster Harold LeganiaEdna Karr (New Orleans, LA) 6-3 / 250 0.8448
2010 Brewster Marek LenkiewiczVictor J Andrew (Bolingbrook, IL) 6-5 / 250 0.8484
2010 Brewster Devon WrightJ. P. Taravella (Pompano Beach, FL) 6-0 / 190 0.8573
2010 Brewster Brock VereenValencia (Valencia, CA) 6-0 / 175 0.859
2010 Brewster Donnell KirkwoodAtlantic (Delray Beach, FL) 5-10 / 197 0.8622
2010 Brewster James ManuelWarren Central (Indianapolis, IN) 6-2 / 200 0.8653
2010 Brewster Lamonte EdwardsWoodbury Senior (Saint Paul, MN) 6-2 / 215 0.8813
2010 Brewster Jimmy GjereIrondale Senior (Saint Paul, MN) 6-7 / 300 0.9072
2010 Brewster James GillumPearl River (Pearl River, LA) 5-11 / 190 0.75
2010 Brewster Dexter ForemanManvel (Manvel, TX) 6-1 / 220 0.75
Year Name Size Rating
2014 Jerry Gibson 6-3 / 220 0.815
2014 Jared Weyler 6-4 / 280 0.8015
2014 Gary Moore 6-4 / 285 0.7993
2015 Winston DeLattiboudere 6-3 / 216 0.8347
2015 Shannon Brooks 6-0 / 205 0.8431
2015 Quinn Oseland 6-6 / 301 0.8553
2015 Julian Huff 6-0 / 225 0.8033
2015 Jonathan Femi-Cole 6-0 / 218 0.827
2015 Jacob Huff 5-10 / 205 0.8155
2015 Colton Beebe 6-3 / 252 0.7996
2015 Bryce Witham 6-4 / 240 0.8219
2015 Bronson Dovich 6-5 / 295 0.8391
2015 Antonio Shenault 5-11 / 185 0.8284
2016 Tyler Johnson 6-3 / 187 0.8643
2016 Thomas Barber 6-1 / 225 0.8425
2016 Tai'yon Devers 6-4 / 220 0.8301
2016 Seth Green 6-4 / 216 0.8813
2016 Sam Schlueter 6-6 / 290 0.8603
2016 Phillip Howard 5-11 / 185 0.8509
2016 Ko Kieft 6-4 / 230 0.8037
2016 Kiondre Thomas 6-0 / 181 0.8466
2016 Kamal Martin 6-4 / 230 0.8518
2016 Donnell Greene 6-7 / 345 0.7933
2016 Conner Olson 6-5 / 295 0.8441
2016 Coney Durr 5-10.5 / 193 0.8375
2016 Carter Coughlin 6-4 / 223 0.9566
2016 Antoine Winfield 5-10 / 196 0.8285