I wish this conversation would just die. Unfortunately when people use extreme hyperbole and completely inaccurate comments like the above to "prove" their "point" that resurrects this stupid argument. Those that feel the need to protect tubby, please let this comment go by without "proving" him "wrong" and can we all just move on.
Tubbys exit was/is highly open to interpretation based on our own viewpoints of the progress or lack there of in the program. the only facts are that tubby left the program after experiencing success the program hadn't seen recently and he is now coaching elsewhere.
The rest is pointless and frankly, arguing for or against him makes this place unreadable