Blue chip quarterback recruits are transferring at an alarming rate - Stewart Mandel

Iceland12

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 12, 2008
Messages
24,453
Reaction score
2,285
Points
113
Whether it’s five-star Stanford commit Davis Mills, Clemson early enrollee Hunter Johnson, touted Alabama pledge Tua Tagovailoa or Michigan-bound Dylan McCaffrey, all as of this moment are viewed as the quarterbacks of the future at their respective programs.

In reality, if recent averages hold, only one of those four names will go on to become a star, another might start for a couple of years — and the other two will finish their careers at another school.

If it seems like high-profile quarterback recruits transfer at an unusually high rate, well, it’s because they do. Using 247Sports’ composite rankings, FOX Sports researched the careers of every Top 50 quarterback recruit that signed from 2011-14.

Exactly half — 100 of 200 — transferred from their original school.

Which means there’s a 1-in-2 chance Gatorade Player of the Year Tate Martell will leave Ohio State roughly halfway through his time there. It’s 50-50 whether five-star Texas A&M early enrollee Kellen Mond finishes his career in College Station. (Aggies fans are conditioned at this point to seeing touted quarterbacks transfer.)

It didn’t used to be this way.

Go back 15 years to 2002, when future Texas star Vince Young sat atop the recruiting rankings. Of the 24 quarterbacks to earn composite four- or five-star ratings, all but five finished their careers at the school they signed with out of high school. Only a few (Young, Ohio State’s Troy Smith, Michigan State’s Drew Stanton) emerged as stars. Far more waited their turn and started eventually, or, in a few cases, changed positions or joined the baseball team...

https://www.foxsports.com/college-f...ua-tagovailoa-michigan-dylan-mccaffrey-013017
 

Wonder when they'll start to realize that if they just signed with a different school from the get-go (one that doesn't already have 4 other 4-5* QBs) they would greatly increase their chances of playing time. For example, they could sign with the Gophers.
 

Wonder when they'll start to realize that if they just signed with a different school from the get-go (one that doesn't already have 4 other 4-5* QBs) they would greatly increase their chances of playing time. For example, they could sign with the Gophers.

The current system doesn't hurt them that much. They get to go to a school that has a known track record for developing QBs and if they lose the QB battle, they can transfer to another school.
 

The current system doesn't hurt them that much. They get to go to a school that has a known track record for developing QBs and if they lose the QB battle, they can transfer to another school.

The penalty is sitting out a year and also not ideal to have to learn a new school, new football system, etc. So there at least some incentive to starting out in the right place.
 

Just for fun, where top QBs in 2017 from the NFL went to school:

Michigan
Miami (OH)
USC
NC State
Georgia
Purdue
Florida St
Utah
Boston College
Michigan St
California
NDSU
NC State/Wisconsin
California
Houston
Fresno St
Ole Miss
UCF
Sam Houston St
Oregon
Mississippi St
Northwestern
TCU
Auburn
Iowa
Delaware
NC State
Notre Dame
Vandy
VA Tech
North Carolina
 


The penalty is sitting out a year and also not ideal to have to learn a new school, new football system, etc. So there at least some incentive to starting out in the right place.

Well sure, if you could tell the future.

Take Jake Fromm. His choice looks brilliant in hindsight. He went to Georgia, played with a ton of talent, played for a national championship, etc. However, he went to a team that had a great FR QB (Eason). However, we could all envision the scenario where he never got to take a snap at Georgia. Let's assume Eason doesn't get hurt and that Fields (2018 recruit) is as special as he seems. . .Fromm would be transferring.
 

Interesting list. By my quick count:

Helmet school - 5
Other Power 5 - 19
Group 5 - 4
FCS - 3
 

Interesting list. By my quick count:

Helmet school - 5
Other Power 5 - 19
Group 5 - 4
FCS - 3

And just so everyone knows, I just took the qualified QBs. Doesn't include guys like Andrew Luck, Bradford, Bridgewater, etc. Someone probably has more time to come up with a better list.
 

I think VV took the right route -- go to CC for two years to get playing time in and then pick the University that needs a QB. By doing the CC route you don't need to sit out a year when you transfer. He got playing time instead of watching and waiting his turn. There's a lot of talk about which QB will start, but I'm sure VV will see the field and get a solid chance to show he's the guy.
 



Well sure, if you could tell the future.

Take Jake Fromm. His choice looks brilliant in hindsight. He went to Georgia, played with a ton of talent, played for a national championship, etc. However, he went to a team that had a great FR QB (Eason). However, we could all envision the scenario where he never got to take a snap at Georgia. Let's assume Eason doesn't get hurt and that Fields (2018 recruit) is as special as he seems. . .Fromm would be transferring.
That could still happen, as well as he played last year.
 

It more has to do with the fact that for the most part QB's are QB's and if they find themselves blocked in terms of playing time they can't easily slide to another position on their existing team. Other blue chip positions generally have multiple options within their own team if it looks like they are stuck on a depth chart..
 




Top Bottom