Maybe I'm jaded. In real life, I've read 100's of police reports, including reports dealing with child abuse, sexual assault, domestic abuse and more. The police report in this case didn't strike me as that shocking. The EOAA report is a different matter - because it contains conclusions and opinions, based on the subjective viewpoint of the EOAA staff. They may be the correct conclusions - but this is not a 100% cut-and-dried issue. It's not as simple as a lot of posters seem to believe.
Bottom line - human beings are capable of some pretty remarkable behavior - both good and bad.