WSJ: ‘30 for 30: Catholics vs. Convicts’ Review: Gripping Gridiron Drama

BleedGopher

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 11, 2008
Messages
60,698
Reaction score
15,935
Points
113
per the Wall Street Journal:

It may not have been Bobby Thomson’s home run, or the Rumble in the Jungle, or even Michael Jordan’s 63 points against Boston in 1986. But the October 1988 showdown between the undefeated University of Miami and undefeated Notre Dame is one of those moments real sports fans remember. They remember where they were. Where they lived. They certainly remember the score.

So the fact that ESPN’s “Catholics vs. Convicts” achieves such a high degree of drama—despite being about one of the more infamous games in the history of college football—is saying something. Even those who don’t know what’s going to happen can sense what’s coming. And yet director Patrick Creadon creates, and maintains, tension. (Note: The plot spoiler of all time was in the title of Kevin Rafferty’s 2008 football documentary—“Harvard Beats Yale 29-29.” Yet it too remains a bona-fide thriller.)

As he tells it, the unbridled loathing between the two schools dated to November 1985, when Gerry Faust—who had already announced his retirement and would be coaching his last game at Notre Dame—brought his woebegone Fighting Irish to meet the vastly superior Hurricanes of Miami. Encouraged by their coach—current Fox sportscaster Jimmy Johnson—Miami players piled on, ran up the score, jeered at Notre Dame from the sidelines and displayed what several of the film’s interviewees recall as no class whatsoever. The final score: 58-7.

Why would Mr. Johnson purposely humiliate a colleague at the end of his career? It’s a question that goes unanswered in any direct way, though Mr. Creadon does cover a lot of other territory, including the various intersections in the lives and careers of coaches and players. Steve Walsh, for instance, a Catholic boy who played high-school ball virtually in Notre Dame’s backyard, was overlooked by that college and went on to play at Miami. Mr. Faust’s successor, Lou Holtz, had gotten the job Jimmy Johnson wanted at his alma mater, Arkansas.

http://www.wsj.com/articles/30-for-...cts-review-gripping-gridiron-drama-1481228994

Go Gophers!!
 

AWESOME! I can still remember the day of this game: October 15, 1988. Game 1 of the World Series when Kirk Gibson hit his HR was later that night.

Miami got jobbed in the 4th quarter on a phantom fumble when Cleveland Gary was, at the very worst, down before he fumbled, which would have given Miami a 1st & Goal. He probably scored the TD though. Neither call occurred as ND got the ball. Miami then scored in the last minute & went for 2 (I still love when coaches do it & go for the win, even when Brewster did it against Northwestern in '07).
 

Steve Walsh, for instance, a Catholic boy who played high-school ball virtually in Notre Dame’s backyard, was overlooked by that college and went on to play at Miami. Mr. Faust’s successor, Lou Holtz, had gotten the job Jimmy Johnson wanted at his alma mater, Arkansas.

Interesting perspective that St. Paul (~500 miles from South Bend) is "virtually in Notre Dame's backyard."
 

Yea...ND has had a bit of a Cretin pipeline throughout the years. Maybe that's what they meant.

Looking forward to this doc.
 

Yea...ND has had a bit of a Cretin pipeline throughout the years. Maybe that's what they meant.

Looking forward to this doc.
+1 In other words, what you said. Notre Dame works the Cretin feeder schools as well. Of course, the Catholic experience is what they are selling.
 


Back in early Sept. 1992 I drove down to Kinnick Stadium for #1 Miami at Iowa. Before both teams took the field, about 3 Miami players came out and walked around the perimeter of the field and taunted the Iowa fans, which I completely enjoyed. The Iowa fans went berserk with anger. They were a brash bunch to be sure.
 






Top Bottom