View Full Version : How will the crowd react to Clem Haskins' return to the Barn on Tuesday?
BleedGopher
12-27-2009, 08:13 AM
Shooter says that Clem will return as part of the celebration of the Elite 8 team. I believe Yvette came back a year or so ago, but this will be Clem's first return to the Barn. How do you think the crowd will react?
I really hope the U does it right and not the way they "honored" the 82 team a few years back or the almumni last year. I hope they have highlights, announce each player during halftime, etc.
Go Gophers!!
Gopher4Life
12-27-2009, 08:43 AM
The crowd should knock him onto his corrupt ass with boos. Clem lied, cheated, disgraced our program, and set up the Monson years. I'm not sure how he could have done more harm to Gopher Nation. If truth were told, he was finally caught, but we'll likely never know the full extent of the deceit during his tenure. Minnesota Nice be damned when Clem slithers onto the court again.
Lincoln gopher
12-27-2009, 08:53 AM
The crowd should knock him onto his corrupt ass with boos. Clem lied, cheated, disgraced our program, and set up the Monson years. I'm not sure how he could have done more harm to Gopher Nation. If truth were told, he was finally caught, but we'll likely never know the full extent of the deceit during his tenure. Minnesota Nice be damned when Clem slithers onto the court again.
Can't say I disagree, Clem f**ked up the Gopher program worse than the prior two "scandals" ever dreamed of doing. The worst part was that Clem did it while most Minnesota fans adored him and what he was doing with the program. He was loved in Minnesota until the news came out.
GopherHomer
12-27-2009, 09:50 AM
He should be cheered. He did nothing that other programs don't do. I blame the woman who couldn't keep her mouth shut and the pioneer press. All my favorite Gopher memories are with Clem at the helm...the man wanted to win. Kudos. If Monson wasn't such an ineffectual *&^!#*&^!#*&^!#*&^!#*&^!#*&^!#, we barely would have felt the penalties. Programs get punished and recover all the time...you can't take away the memories.
GopherJake
12-27-2009, 10:14 AM
He should be cheered. He did nothing that other programs don't do. I blame the ... pioneer press.
Yep. What happened to the code of journalism? Great point G-Homer! The only reason Royce and Trevor aren't playing is because of the stupid media. Mind your own business, media, and our program wouldn't have so many problems. No surprise that this same media stuck its nose into the business of the Iraq war and found out about torture and lies about WMD's. Stupid media. What we don't know doesn't hurt us. Stay out of it. Stupid media. Everything's all your fault.
Studwell55
12-27-2009, 10:26 AM
Clem's crimes were more serious than most: he corrupted his players' educations.
He should not be allowed on campus, let alone into Williams.
Blizzard
12-27-2009, 10:47 AM
He should not be allowed on campus, let alone into Williams.
I can't say I disagree. If they're expecting a warm, forgiving, welcome for him, I'm not sure why.
He was instrumental in Tubby's hiring and he should be thanked for that, but that's about it.
bassy123
12-27-2009, 11:05 AM
He should be cheered. He did nothing that other programs don't do. I blame the woman who couldn't keep her mouth shut and the pioneer press. All my favorite Gopher memories are with Clem at the helm...the man wanted to win. Kudos. If Monson wasn't such an ineffectual *&^!#*&^!#*&^!#*&^!#*&^!#*&^!#, we barely would have felt the penalties. Programs get punished and recover all the time...you can't take away the memories.
after all that money we gave him to go away he should be able to handle a few boos.
Mulligan
12-27-2009, 11:19 AM
The crowd should knock him onto his corrupt ass with boos. Clem lied, cheated, disgraced our program, and set up the Monson years. I'm not sure how he could have done more harm to Gopher Nation. If truth were told, he was finally caught, but we'll likely never know the full extent of the deceit during his tenure. Minnesota Nice be damned when Clem slithers onto the court again.
It's all hypothetical since in a way he doesn't even exist, but how would you react to Bobby Jackson being introduced again at Williams? Clem was in charge and lied publicly, but many of the players from "the cheating years" knew what was going on. Would you also treat them as pariahs?
Holy Man
12-27-2009, 11:50 AM
No cheers from me. Did he ever make a public apology to the fans and the institution? Studwell is correct. He corrupted educations, and brought a black eye to the entire university and not just the basketball program.
Carlson 79
12-27-2009, 11:54 AM
I'd prefer stone, cold silence.
gophergv
12-27-2009, 01:06 PM
You can't tell me 1997 didn't happen, I lived it.
MN Gopher Fan
12-27-2009, 01:35 PM
I'll cheer...he lead the gophers to what Memphis and other programs do now...and there was a story about Clem a year ago or so on ESPN (i think) and it was really well done
akgopher
12-27-2009, 01:40 PM
I can't believe he's coming back, that's just bold. It's going to be interesting. The worst aspect in regards to Clem is that he presented himself as a self-righteous coach and left so many of us thinking he could've created a dynasty if he cheated like the others.
I went to the summer league at the Target Center when Dwayne Casey brought him back. The arena exit on the floor handles a double filed line, guess who walked out beside my left shoulder? I remember exchanging a glare with him, he appeared guarded. I thought it was bold for him to appear at the Target Center, never dreamed he'd show up at Williams. Too bad I'm going to be out of town. I probably wouldn't boo, but would love to be there to take in the reception.
Rick Mons
12-27-2009, 01:51 PM
I'd prefer stone, cold silence.
+1
Xtreme
12-27-2009, 01:54 PM
Tubby and Clem are friends, so be polite out of respect for Tubby.
Skage
12-27-2009, 02:10 PM
Clem messed up, but I never felt it was done with malice towards the program or because of vanity. I think he wanted to keep kids eligible so they could live their dream because without basketball, I'm not sure some of them would have had any future to think about. Clem did a disservice to their education, but ultimately that responsibility rests with those who chose to cheat on themselves! Perhaps that is what makes for a great college coach - the person who can bring out the best in players, both on and off the court. A coach who can teach life lessons that creates men who become productive members of society when their basketball skills can no longer carry them. A coach who can balance the demands of winning, graduation rates, and managing the lives of young men. Perhaps Clem focused too much on the basketball side of things while losing site of the longer term objectives.
Sometimes the sanctimony on this site is over the top. I'm amazed at the posters who have apparently never messed up and are able to sit in judgment of others. People deserve a 2nd chance and forgiveness (See Royce White!) - at least that is what I've been taught since I went to Sunday School.
It hurt to see the Gophers fall as far as they did. But what is done is done and it is way past the time to move on. Clem helped to give us a lot of thrills and I'll choose to appreciate that. I also appreciate that Tubby is now at the helm and seems to be an excellent example of a "great college coach" that I discussed above, and I don't think there are too many of them!
Go Gophers!
I hope Clem receives a nice ovation.
Studwell: "Corrupting kids educations"? Surely, you can't really believe that anything that went on with Gopher student athlete "educations" was any different than what goes on all across the country.
If Clem was "cheating" worse than anyone else, I'd love to know why we ended up with guys like Russ Archambeault, Kyle Sanden, and Kevin Loge as recruits. Further, I'd wonder why we didn't end up with Doug Wrenn, but I know the answer to that.
WAGopher
12-27-2009, 02:43 PM
Was it ever proven that Clem knew about Ganglehoff helping the players academically cheat? IIRC, Clem was proven to be guilty of some of other things, like helping players through some money problems.
I am unsure what I would do. I am guessing he will receive mostly a positive response from the crowd with some boos mixed in.
Swaggerson
12-27-2009, 04:04 PM
The only thing he did for me was improve my seating priority!
SelectionSunday
12-27-2009, 04:38 PM
Not sure how I'll react until the moment arrives. I'm mad at Clem (but not bitter) for what happened to the program, but despite what he did I have empathy for him as a human being. We all have our crosses to bear. My hunch is silence is the route I'll take. I know for sure I will not boo him.
Friend Of Tubby
12-27-2009, 04:55 PM
Tubby and Clem are friends, so be polite out of respect for Tubby.
Well stated.
station19
12-27-2009, 05:03 PM
Well stated.
+2
GortonsFisherman011
12-27-2009, 05:11 PM
I will cheer, and will hope the rest of the student section does the same. Although most of them may not remember who he is.
station19
12-27-2009, 05:48 PM
Well stated.
I should of stated this earlier but: Also in respect to the other student athletes of that team that I presume will be there. We sometimes group people by a small number of 'bad apples'.
go 31
12-27-2009, 05:51 PM
If you boo Clem, you'll be booing the Elite 8 team and Tubby at the same time. Don't be responsible for the peripheral damage. Remember that the Elite 8 team and their coach are still in the recordbooks.
98VQueens
12-27-2009, 06:32 PM
If you boo Clem, you'll be booing the Elite 8 team and Tubby at the same time. Don't be responsible for the peripheral damage. Remember that the Elite 8 team and their coach are still in the recordbooks.
+1
akgopher
12-27-2009, 06:51 PM
Too bad his presence will overshadow the reason for the celebration Willie Burton, Jon Shikenjanski, Richard Coffey, Walter Bond, Kevin Lynch, Melvin Newbern, etc. being back in the barn. I wish he'd stay home.
Brew_recruit
12-27-2009, 07:20 PM
He will get a standing ovation from me for sure
GoGoGophers
12-27-2009, 07:42 PM
Was it ever proven that Clem knew about Ganglehoff helping the players academically cheat? IIRC, Clem was proven to be guilty of some of other things, like helping players through some money problems.
Um...yes. Repeatedly in the investigation, including a cancelled check from Clem to Gangelhoff to shut her up. He was the mastermind of the entire fraud, let's not try to re-write history here.
Clem destroyed the U's reputation as both an athletic and academic institution. At lease Coach Cal and Memphis never claimed to have an academic reputation to tarnish. The U does. I am not just a basketball fan but an alum, and the reputation of the UNIVERSITY matters to me.
I will boo the ever-living sh!t out of him if he walks onto the floor at Williams. He deserves it.
golfinggopher
12-27-2009, 07:50 PM
I'd hate to see people boo the ol' Clemster although I do understand why some will. Growing up in outstate MN my first memories of Gopher basketball are watching Clem taking his jacket off and getting his players AND the crowd fired up! By the time I turned 16, my first trip to the cities was piling a bunch of my buddies in my car and driving down to Williams arena to watch Clem and the Gophers play. I still remember how excited my ol' man would get watching him on the sidelines.
He is probably the biggest reason I fell in love with Gophers sports. I'm sorry, I just couldn't bring myself to boo the guy! I know he did some bad things, but I really believe he thought in his head that he was was helping these kids out. Now, don't get me wrong, that doesn't make it right, but I've got a soft spot for the guy and wish him all the best on his farm in Kentucky.
idagopher
12-27-2009, 08:04 PM
just be Christiana nd turn the other cheek, forgive
Jim V2
12-27-2009, 11:28 PM
I'd prefer stone, cold silence.
+1
Moses87
12-28-2009, 05:18 AM
Clem messed up, but I never felt it was done with malice towards the program or because of vanity. I think he wanted to keep kids eligible so they could live their dream because without basketball, I'm not sure some of them would have had any future to think about. Clem did a disservice to their education, but ultimately that responsibility rests with those who chose to cheat on themselves! Perhaps that is what makes for a great college coach - the person who can bring out the best in players, both on and off the court. A coach who can teach life lessons that creates men who become productive members of society when their basketball skills can no longer carry them. A coach who can balance the demands of winning, graduation rates, and managing the lives of young men. Perhaps Clem focused too much on the basketball side of things while losing site of the longer term objectives.
Sometimes the sanctimony on this site is over the top. I'm amazed at the posters who have apparently never messed up and are able to sit in judgment of others. People deserve a 2nd chance and forgiveness (See Royce White!) - at least that is what I've been taught since I went to Sunday School.
It hurt to see the Gophers fall as far as they did. But what is done is done and it is way past the time to move on. Clem helped to give us a lot of thrills and I'll choose to appreciate that. I also appreciate that Tubby is now at the helm and seems to be an excellent example of a "great college coach" that I discussed above, and I don't think there are too many of them!
Go Gophers!
Kids get 2nd chances....coaches KNOW better and while he might have rationalized what he was doing was in the best interest of the kids, it was still cheating...He made a choice and now has to live with it.
We shouldn't honor someone who disgraced the program and made the wrong choices.
akgopher
12-28-2009, 08:02 AM
Um...yes. Repeatedly in the investigation, including a cancelled check from Clem to Gangelhoff to shut her up. He was the mastermind of the entire fraud, let's not try to re-write history here.
Clem destroyed the U's reputation as both an athletic and academic institution. At lease Coach Cal and Memphis never claimed to have an academic reputation to tarnish. The U does. I am not just a basketball fan but an alum, and the reputation of the UNIVERSITY matters to me.
I will boo the ever-living sh!t out of him if he walks onto the floor at Williams. He deserves it.
Do I remember right that he tried to keep the women assaulted by his players quiet too?
Is it hearsay that Pryzbilla showed up on campus with little expectations for being a student-athlete and Voshon Lenard was a clown in classes?
He just wanted to help the kids. Would you hold your own kids to those expectations?
oleboy41
12-28-2009, 09:27 AM
I grew up with Clem on the sidelines. The guy has been publicly shamed and has been out of basketball. He helped bring Tubby here and has only said good things about the program. He screwed up but there's no need to be bitter anymore. Personally my favorite basketball memories were the Final 4 season. I don't care if they're off the books now. Truth is (like it or not) most teams cheat in some way. Our players still had to play and they did a great job of that. I'd cheer him.
go 31
12-28-2009, 09:58 AM
Our players still had to play and they did a great job of that. I'd cheer him.
+1
ski-u-mah
12-28-2009, 11:18 AM
That would be tough for me as well. I loved Clem, think he had the players best interests at heart and I promise you this was probably being done at a ton of other schools, he just got caught.
That said, it was also an unforgivable offense.
I guess I'm surpised he's coming back. Could be very awkward.
GopherRock
12-28-2009, 11:32 AM
I'm surprised that Mark Rotenberg didn't go totally crazy on Joel Maturi for letting Clem show up. As far as I know, he's still persona non grata in The Barn.
oleboy41
12-28-2009, 01:05 PM
That would be tough for me as well. I loved Clem, think he had the players best interests at heart and I promise you this was probably being done at a ton of other schools, he just got caught.
That said, it was also an unforgivable offense.
I guess I'm surpised he's coming back. Could be very awkward.
Why is it unforgivable? Did he murder your family member or something? He cheated. He got caught. It happens all the time. Its not right but everything is forgivable in major college sports. Reggie Bush had his family living in a mansion while in school. Dirt poor kids are driving new cars around campus. Guys go 4 years and barely attend a class, but for some reason this is unforgivable?
Gopher Bandanna Guy
12-28-2009, 01:58 PM
Were I in attendance of whatever game this is to happen at, I would be forced to politely applaud.
For no other reason than that his teams produced an enormous amount of entertainment value for me when I was a student, and I have to thank him for that. Scandal or no.
Halsey Hall
12-28-2009, 02:14 PM
Is Jon Shikenjanski related to Jim Shikenjanski?
Plinnius
12-28-2009, 02:55 PM
Anybody bringing batteries?
Gopher4Life
12-28-2009, 05:07 PM
Homer,
>>He should be cheered.<<
Even your parents must be ashamed of you.
Bandanna,
>>Scandal or no.<<
I respect your opinion, but that's precisely the problem. Falling standards. Anything goes. Situation ethics. Increasingly amoral society. Heck, we even paid Clem when he left.
Carlson,
>>I'd prefer stone, cold silence.<<
Stones might be more appropriate.
oak_street1981
12-28-2009, 08:17 PM
he won with paid players I'll be more receptive to all this outrage over Clem.
I'll be cheering for Clem loudly, that is if they give us a chance to cheer, unlike the awful joke of
an "honor" provided to the '82 team.
Sam Gilbert and others corrupted the UCLA program beyond belief and everyone knew it. Wooden knew it and the NCAA knew it, yet no one lifted a finger to stop it.
They threw the book at Tark and Muss, while Wooden and Kentucky ran wild.
Bobby Knight called out Kentucky for cheating years ago and he called out Callipari last week. Knight is a true hero.
Spare us whining regarding Clem, and try to put it all into perspective. When the NCAA does something about Calipari and others, I'll try to muster some outrage over Clem.
Wooden,due to his tolerance of Sam Gilbert, was as crooked as it gets. Call out Wooden, then you can be "outraged" by Clem Haskins.
jamiche
12-28-2009, 10:22 PM
he won with paid players I'll be more receptive to all this outrage over Clem.
I'll be cheering for Clem loudly, that is if they give us a chance to cheer, unlike the awful joke of
an "honor" provided to the '82 team.
Sam Gilbert and others corrupted the UCLA program beyond belief and everyone knew it. Wooden knew it and the NCAA knew it, yet no one lifted a finger to stop it.
They threw the book at Tark and Muss, while Wooden and Kentucky ran wild.
Bobby Knight called out Kentucky for cheating years ago and he called out Callipari last week. Knight is a true hero.
Spare us whining regarding Clem, and try to put it all into perspective. When the NCAA does something about Calipari and others, I'll try to muster some outrage over Clem.
Wooden,due to his tolerance of Sam Gilbert, was as crooked as it gets. Call out Wooden, then you can be "outraged" by Clem Haskins.
I'm not going to boo Clem and I'm not going to applaud. I think the best thing the crowd can do is remain silent.
What Clem did was wrong and honoring or acknowledging him is inappropriate. What disturbs me more is how Wooden is portrayed as a saint. A nice, mild mannered and articulate man who was also one of the dirtiest coaches in the history of college basketball. Every one of his star players was bought and paid for by Sam Gilbert and a couple of his pals. People get angry when the dirty little secret is discussed but, without Gilbert, Wooden is a nobody.
MillionMoves
12-28-2009, 10:30 PM
Clem Haskins is a far better person than the typical poster on here throwing stones.
Moses87
12-29-2009, 12:42 AM
Clem Haskins is a far better person than the typical poster on here throwing stones.
How can you vouch for the character of a man who blatantly cheated, got caught, denied it and then left without so much as an apology? Now he comes back and you expect us to just remember the wins??? Sorry, his legacy is stained beyond repair...IF I were in attendance I'd cheer the players but sit down and stay silent during clem's introduction.
Is Clem finally going to hold the press conference he promised 10 years ago when he would tell his side of the story?
Um...yes. Repeatedly in the investigation, including a cancelled check from Clem to Gangelhoff to shut her up. He was the mastermind of the entire fraud, let's not try to re-write history here.
Clem destroyed the U's reputation as both an athletic and academic institution. At lease Coach Cal and Memphis never claimed to have an academic reputation to tarnish. The U does. I am not just a basketball fan but an alum, and the reputation of the UNIVERSITY matters to me.
I will boo the ever-living sh!t out of him if he walks onto the floor at Williams. He deserves it.
Thank you!! :clap:Thank you!! :clap:Thank you!! :clap: The revisionists were starting to hijack this thread.
Here's a recap of what Clem is responsible for: Academic Fraud; Unethical Conduct; Provision of Extra Benefits; Failure to Comply with Eligibility Requirements; Impermissible Special Arrangement; Recruiting Inducement; Violation of Eligibility/Transfer Requirements; Violation of Supplemental Pay Provisions; Violation of Rules Compliance Principal; Lack of Institutional Control.
We lost a decade of hoops' basketball and continue to endure national shame because of Clem and his cheating ways. And for all you fools who sing the "Everyone cheats, we just got caught;" your mother is embarrassed for you.
Was it ever proven that Clem knew about Ganglehoff helping the players academically cheat? IIRC, Clem was proven to be guilty of some of other things, like helping players through some money problems.
Here's your answer from the NCAA Report file in October, 2000:
"The head coach was knowledgeable about and complicit in the academic fraud in which the
secretary and academic counselor engaged. The head coach knew of the secretary’s
involvement with student-athletes and her preparation of course work on their behalf.
Similarly, he knew of the activities of the academic counselor in arranging and directing the
work that the secretary did with and for men’s basketball student-athletes. By his overall
control of the men’s basketball program and the environment thereby fostered, the head
coach facilitated the activities of both the academic counselor and the secretary. His support
of their activities included special benefits provided them by him or by the men’s basketball
program. Among the benefits to the secretary was a trip to Hawaii with the team and $3000
paid to her from the personal funds of the head coach. Among the benefits to the academic
counselor was a car lease paid for a period of six years by the head coach from his personal
funds. The head coach provided three separate and detailed responses to the letter of official
inquiry sent him by the enforcement staff, responses that are discussed in this report in the
context of particular allegations involving him. The head coach’s final response was
provided two days prior to the hearing with the specific authorization of the chair. The head
coach did not appear at the hearing before the committee."
Pewterschmidt
12-29-2009, 07:39 AM
Anyone one that cheers Clem (much less gives him a standing ovation) should really check where they are in life. I'm not saying you have to boo the guy but to pat the guy on the back in the very building and on the very campus that he shamed, disgraced, punched-in-the-b@lls, spit-on, and sucker-punched is beyond stupid.
Everyone cheats in CB? Many of you sound like Terrelle Pryor. Whatever. Have some standards. I have no time for those that tolerate that type of behavior. You have problems.
jmag21
12-29-2009, 08:15 AM
Guess what. Unlike you sanctimonious folks on here, I will be cheering Clem as loud as I possibly can. Did he cheat? I have almost no doubt about it. Was it inexcusable? Absolutely. Should he have been fired? Unquestionably. Does that mean that the man should be booed, mocked, and harassed when he returns? No way. Look, I have had the chance to meet Clem a couple of times. He's an unbelievably nice guy. When I was growing up, his teams brought me a lot of joy. Sure, there was the heartbreak when the scandal broke, and at that point, Clem had to go. But my opinion has always always been that Clem was basically a good man, and that he (in my perhaps naive opinion) was able to persuade himself that the academic help was simply giving underprivileged kids a chance to succeed. I'm not going to excuse his behavior by saying that "everybody else did it, so it's okay." I am convinced that every single program in the country breaks NCAA rules to some extent, but that doesn't make it okay.
Look, maybe it's impossible to reconcile my deep antipathy for John Calipari with my still great regard for Clem Haskins. What can I say. However, for what it's worth, I'll be cheering for Clem when he gets back. I wouldn't mind hearing an apology from him though.
oleboy41
12-29-2009, 08:17 AM
Anyone one that cheers Clem (much less gives him a standing ovation) should really check where they are in life. I'm not saying you have to boo the guy but to pat the guy on the back in the very building and on the very campus that he shamed, disgraced, punched-in-the-b@lls, spit-on, and sucker-punched is beyond stupid.
Everyone cheats in CB? Many of you sound like Terrelle Pryor. Whatever. Have some standards. I have no time for those that tolerate that type of behavior. You have problems.
lol. Get off your high horse. Just because some of us acknowledge that he actually did some good while here and appreciate those things instead of simply being pissed means we have issues? Here's the truth: CBB is entertainment. Do we want to have good kids who are on the honor roll and honorably people? Sure we do. But at the end of the day its entertainment first. Monson did a great job of cleaning things up and making kids go to class, but the Barn was half full because he didn't win. People weren't shelling out their dollars to watch a team of good kids lose. I was born in 84. Most of my youth was spent watching Clem on the sidelines. He was a good coach that had a decent run at a midlevel major conference school. I, along with the rest of the state was very entertained during that great Final 4 run. He cheated and got caught. He's been essentially banished from the state that loved him for 10 years and pretty much from all of CBB. His wrongs have been well documented and he's paid the price of them already. I would choose to acknowledge the positive he did while here this time instead of simply rehashing the same negatives. Should that whole era be a black hole? Bobby Jackson still gets cheered when he plays in the Target Center. Why can we cheer him without having to 'check where we are in life' and not Clem? I'd say you check where you are since you're obviously still bitter about what happened over 10 years ago
[QUOTE=oak_street1981;157328]
They threw the book at Tark and Muss, while Wooden and Kentucky ran wild.
Bobby Knight called out Kentucky for cheating years ago and he called out Callipari last week. Knight is a true hero.QUOTE]
Kentucky has gotten their due with six major NCAA infractions. Here's proof of their legacy:
http://rushthecourt.files.wordpress.com/2008/08/kentucky-shame.jpg
howeda7
12-29-2009, 08:44 AM
I'd hate to see people boo the ol' Clemster although I do understand why some will. Growing up in outstate MN my first memories of Gopher basketball are watching Clem taking his jacket off and getting his players AND the crowd fired up! By the time I turned 16, my first trip to the cities was piling a bunch of my buddies in my car and driving down to Williams arena to watch Clem and the Gophers play. I still remember how excited my ol' man would get watching him on the sidelines.
He is probably the biggest reason I fell in love with Gophers sports. I'm sorry, I just couldn't bring myself to boo the guy! I know he did some bad things, but I really believe he thought in his head that he was was helping these kids out. Now, don't get me wrong, that doesn't make it right, but I've got a soft spot for the guy and wish him all the best on his farm in Kentucky.
I tend to agree with this. What he did was wrong, but I think he justfied it in his own mind. The players he was 'helping' were never going to be stellar students or graduate of thier own accord. All many of them had was basketball, and he believed the most important thing was to not let that be taken away from them, no matter what. It doesn't make it right, but I consider it less sleazy then many of the things Coach Cal and others have done.
I hope everyone cheers him. If nothing else, booing him would ruin a celebration of the rest of that team that as far as we know had nothing to do with the scandal. It would also disrespect Tubby. However it ended, Clem was our coach for 13 years, and most of the memories he left us were good. Focus on those and save the bad stuff for another forum.
ski-u-mah
12-29-2009, 09:53 AM
Why is it unforgivable? Did he murder your family member or something? He cheated. He got caught. It happens all the time. Its not right but everything is forgivable in major college sports. Reggie Bush had his family living in a mansion while in school. Dirt poor kids are driving new cars around campus. Guys go 4 years and barely attend a class, but for some reason this is unforgivable?
Why is it unforgivable? Did he murder your family member or something?
Obviously I'm not comparing this to murder, and I even stated / acknowledged in my post that there is no way we where the only ones that did this. But what he got caught for is very major in the eyes of the NCAA, the school and most fans on this site. And it cannot be tolerated by a major college level coach (or probably anywhere for that matter).
That said, I am one that also looks at all the good things Clem did as well.
go 31
12-29-2009, 10:08 AM
I hope everyone cheers him. If nothing else, booing him would ruin a celebration of the rest of that team that as far as we know had nothing to do with the scandal. It would also disrespect Tubby.
+1
watertown 1987 guy n
12-29-2009, 11:15 AM
I'll cheer the guy for the great memories even if the wins don't count in the record books - sound screwy, I know, but it was some great basketball.
go 31
12-29-2009, 01:01 PM
There were no sanctions prior to the 1993-94 season so this is the most recent team that we can officially celebrate for NCAA success. Some of the guys on the 1990 team have rarely or never attended games in the Barn since then and even the guys who come regularly would be hurt by boos for Coach. If you need to get rid of some latent anger, kick your dog. No, post another irate thread.
SelectionSunday
12-29-2009, 01:22 PM
". ... this is the most recent team that we can officially celebrate for NCAA success. Some of the guys on the 1990 team have rarely or never attended games in the Barn since then and even the guys who come regularly would be hurt by boos for Coach. If you need to get rid of some latent anger, kick your dog."
Excellent summation. Out of respect for the guys who played for and love(d) Clem, if you feel the need to boo (completely understandable), let your silence do the talking. I'm pretty sure Willie, Shik, Melvin, Lynch, etc., don't want to hear the man who coached them booed out of Williams Arena. Again, I understand the hurt from Gopher fans, but rise above what Clem did to the program and take the high road. If you hate Clem's guts, fine, but put that aside for one evening and make it a special night for his former players.
Hearty applause (for former players) = good;
Uncomfortable applause/silence (toward Clem) = OK;
Booing = bad (and unfair to the men who played for Clem).
That's my sermon for the day.
There were no sanctions prior to the 1993-94 season so this is the most recent team that we can officially celebrate for NCAA success. Some of the guys on the 1990 team have rarely or never attended games in the Barn since then and even the guys who come regularly would be hurt by boos for Coach. If you need to get rid of some latent anger, kick your dog. No, post another irate thread.
If Clem doesn't want to hear boos, then he should have acknowledged the wrongdoing in his tenure and apologized for it sometime in the past 10 years. The U of M took a huge hit for his actions; meanwhile he flees to his farm in Kenutcky with a bundle of cash and bunkers down for an entire decade. He has never made a public statement about any of his transgressions and has never accepted responsibility. I personally won't be booing but he has had numerous opportunities to atone and yet, every time he has decided to bury his head in the sand.
station19
12-29-2009, 02:39 PM
". ... this is the most recent team that we can officially celebrate for NCAA success. Some of the guys on the 1990 team have rarely or never attended games in the Barn since then and even the guys who come regularly would be hurt by boos for Coach. If you need to get rid of some latent anger, kick your dog."
Excellent summation. Out of respect for the guys who played for and love(d) Clem, if you feel the need to boo (completely understandable), let your silence do the talking. I'm pretty sure Willie, Shik, Melvin, Lynch, etc., don't want to hear the man who coached them booed out of Williams Arena. Again, I understand the hurt from Gopher fans, but rise above what Clem did to the program and take the high road. If you hate Clem's guts, fine, but put that aside for one evening and make it a special night for his former players.
Hearty applause (for former players) = good;
Uncomfortable applause/silence (toward Clem) = OK;
Booing = bad (and unfair to the men who played for Clem).
That's my sermon for the day.
Well stated.
I suppose people could boo and have it make a new Sports Center story. Then ESPN could bring up the whole story again. Wouldn't that be great.
WAGopher
12-29-2009, 03:06 PM
Here's your answer from the NCAA Report file in October, 2000:
"The head coach was knowledgeable about and complicit in the academic fraud in which the
secretary and academic counselor engaged. The head coach knew of the secretary’s
involvement with student-athletes and her preparation of course work on their behalf.
Similarly, he knew of the activities of the academic counselor in arranging and directing the
work that the secretary did with and for men’s basketball student-athletes. By his overall
control of the men’s basketball program and the environment thereby fostered, the head
coach facilitated the activities of both the academic counselor and the secretary. His support
of their activities included special benefits provided them by him or by the men’s basketball
program. Among the benefits to the secretary was a trip to Hawaii with the team and $3000
paid to her from the personal funds of the head coach. Among the benefits to the academic
counselor was a car lease paid for a period of six years by the head coach from his personal
funds. The head coach provided three separate and detailed responses to the letter of official
inquiry sent him by the enforcement staff, responses that are discussed in this report in the
context of particular allegations involving him. The head coach’s final response was
provided two days prior to the hearing with the specific authorization of the chair. The head
coach did not appear at the hearing before the committee."
Thank you for digging that up. Those were dark times for the entire Athletic Department (err, well both athletic departments) and fans.
Ogee Oglethorpe
12-29-2009, 06:01 PM
I really have no clue how I would respond. I think silence will speak volumes.
What Clem did was wrong on a lot of levels but I'll relate what bothered me the most.
While born and raised in MN until 26 years old, I didn't get my degree from the U so from an academic standpoint, I'm not THAT embarassed. It was an embarassment to the state where I call home and that stings.
Mostly though, it's about betrayal.
For better or worse, I'm a person that tends to believe the best in people. I believed Clem right up until it was just plain obvious that he WAS responsible for everything. When he said he didn't know, I believed him and I believed him right up until the bitter end.
If that's sanctimonious, so be it. I just felt betrayed and still do to some extent. Those that believed him along with me apparently are all suckers and fools.
I don't hate the man, just myself a little for actually believing him.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.1.11 Copyright © 2012 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.